As someone who’s very conscious of individual fundraising, between my job and my work with Radio Free Monday, I’m seeing an uptick lately in something that I want to talk about. But it’s sensitive, so I’m asking you all to read this in the spirit of help, and understand that any negative tone you take away from this is not my intention.
We live in communities: neighborhood, friends groups, workplaces, fandoms. Part of the point of community is that we help others in that community. But there’s an aversion to the idea of non-reciprocal aid, of accepting financial help that won’t be repaid. And on the one hand I understand; nobody wants to be perceived as a freeloader. But I don’t think we can move past the idea of transactive relationships, an ultimately capitalist idea of how we relate to others, until we stop stigmatizing it, even when we’re the beneficiaries of it.
I see a lot of “normally I would never ask for help” and “I hate to ask for money” and “I’d rather die than accept charity but” and I’m sure that’s true. But…you don’t need to say it.
If someone is inclined to give, it doesn’t matter. If someone isn’t inclined to give, it doesn’t help. Charitable giving on the individual level is not a sales situation. There is no magic combination of words that will induce someone to give if they weren’t going to. And the more we protest that normally we wouldn’t accept, the more we loudly imply that there is shame in asking, the longer it will take us to achieve a compassionate and supportive society.
And also, frankly, you’re making other people feel like shit for asking too. Which I know is not something anyone wants.
If you need to ask for money that sucks and I’m sorry. I’ve been there and it’s a real bind to be in. But I also know that in those situations energy is short, and this is one less thing to expend energy on – instead of protesting your aversion to asking, put that energy into doing one thing to make it easier for folks to give – make your payment app username a hyperlink or a QR code, or make a carrd with your giving options and link that.
Instead of “I would never ask for money normally” say “I know there are many kind people out there who will see this.” Instead of “I hate to make this post” say “You all understand how difficult life can get.” The nonprofit world has done a lot of studying of what makes people give, and positivity is a huge aspect of it. Opening with a negative, particularly a negative that people see constantly in other solicitations, is more likely to hurt your chances than to help.
Don’t follow a script that continues to debase and abuse you. Mainly because it’s not actually helping; there’s no upside to prostrating yourself before an imaginary combative donor. Talk to the people who are actually likely to give, who recognize themselves in your words when you talk about kindness and compassion and who don’t need you to shame yourself in order to be worthy of support. This is not to scold or shame anyone further, but to offer an alternative that is kinder to you and more helpful to the people who want to help.
Do yourselves and your fellow sufferers the kindness of dignity; lord knows you’ve had enough unkindness already.
(via bethanyactually)
